LL97 Enforcement Is Here: What the Latest Article 320 Violations Mean for Your Building
For years, Local Law 97 was something building owners planned for. That phase is over.
Every 2026 reporting date has now passed: the May 1 deadline, the June 30 grace period, and the August 29 extended deadline. The NYC Department of Buildings is issuing Notices of Deficiency and violations under Article 320, the main LL97 compliance pathway, and it is moving unresolved cases to the Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings (OATH). [INSERT: latest violation count and source, if available.]
If a notice from DOB has landed on your desk, or you’re not sure whether your building filed, here’s what you need to know.
What Is Article 320?
Article 320 of Title 28 of the NYC Administrative Code is the standard LL97 pathway. It sets an annual carbon emissions limit for most covered buildings over 25,000 square feet, based on property type and floor area. (Rent-regulated and certain affordable buildings follow Article 321, a separate prescriptive pathway.)
Under Article 320, DOB can penalize a building for three things:
- Failure to file an annual emissions report
- Exceeding the emissions limit
- Filing a false statement
Each one carries very different costs.
What the First Year of Enforcement Showed
DOB’s first-year LL97 report gives a clear picture of how the City is enforcing the law:
- About 95% of covered properties filed, an unusually high compliance rate for a first-year mandate.
- 1,014 Notices of Deficiency went to Article 320 properties that failed to file. After those notices, 239 properties filed and 111 were resolved through exemptions or exceptions. The remaining 664 were referred to OATH.
- 470 Article 320 properties reported emissions over their limits. DOB issued 164 Notices of Deficiency for exceedances, and about 15 properties have paid or are paying penalties totaling roughly $270,000.
- For Article 321 buildings, DOB sent 476 notices and has started issuing $10,000 violations to properties that still haven’t filed.
DOB has said publicly that its goal is 100% filing. Late filers aren’t going to slip through.
Enforcement for the 2026 cycle, covering calendar year 2025, is now underway. Industry reports put recent Notices of Deficiency to non-filing properties at roughly 1,400.
What the Penalties Look Like
| Violation | Penalty |
| Failure to file | $0.50 per square foot, per month, until filed |
| Emissions over the limit | $268 per metric ton of COâ‚‚e over the cap, every year |
| False statement | Up to $500,000 |
Failure to file is the one that catches owners off guard. A 100,000-square-foot building that never files accrues $50,000 a month, whatever its actual emissions are. Unpaid LL97 penalties can also become a lien on the property.
How the Notice of Deficiency Process Works
Based on DOB’s February 2026 enforcement guidance, the process for a failure-to-file notice runs like this:
- DOB issues a Notice of Deficiency (NOD) explaining the problem and how to resolve it.
- You have 60 days from the notice date to respond. Your options:
- Correct it: submit an extension request and your annual emissions report in BEAM. DOB treats this as a zero-penalty
- Pay the civil penalty stated in the notice.
- Challenge the notice by submitting Ticket #17 in the LL97 reporting portal (BEAM), for example if your building isn’t actually covered or the square footage is wrong.
- No action? DOB petitions OATH to start a trial. Even at that point, DOB has said it will request an adjournment if the owner plans to file, and will move to dismiss if a sufficient report comes in before that date.
For an over-the-limit notice, the response window is shorter: 30 days. One option is buying offsets to cover some or all of the excess emissions.
The key point: a failure-to-file notice is often fixable with no penalty if you act inside the window. Waiting is what turns a paperwork problem into a five- or six-figure one.
Filed Already? You’re Not Necessarily in the Clear
DOB is also auditing filed reports. Problems that attract attention include:
- Emissions that don’t reconcile with your LL84 benchmarking data
- Missing fuel sources (steam, fuel oil, a secondary gas meter)
- Square footage or property-use errors
- Owner information that doesn’t match the official owner of record. DOB has said audits won’t close while this is wrong
A report signed by a Registered Design Professional is a legal attestation. Accuracy matters, and the false-statement penalty is there for a reason.
What to Do If You’ve Received a Notice
- Find the notice date. Your 60-day (or 30-day) window starts there, not from when you opened the envelope.
- Check your BEAM account. Confirm what DOB thinks your building’s status, compliance pathway and floor area are.
- Decide on a path: file, dispute or pay. Don’t ignore it.
- Get an RDP-certified report prepared if you haven’t filed.
- Keep records of everything you submit.
How Cotocon Can Help
The Cotocon Group prepares and files PE-certified LL97 reports, answers DOB Notices of Deficiency, and handles Covered Buildings List disputes. Our Compliance 365 platform runs an independent check on LL84 and LL97 data before it reaches the City, so errors get caught before an auditor finds them.
Got a notice? Call (212) 889-6566 today. The response window is short, and the zero-penalty option only exists inside it.
FAQ
What is an LL97 Article 320 violation?
It’s a DOB enforcement action against a building on the standard LL97 pathway, for failing to file an emissions report, exceeding its emissions limit, or filing a false statement.
How much is the LL97 failure-to-file penalty?
$0.50 per square foot of floor area per month until the report is filed.
Can I resolve an LL97 Notice of Deficiency without paying a fine?
For failure-to-file notices, DOB’s enforcement guidance says you can resolve the matter at zero penalty by submitting an extension request and your emissions report within the 60-day window.
What happens if I ignore the notice?
DOB refers the case to OATH for a hearing, and penalties can be imposed and later attached to the property as a lien.
When is the next LL97 report due?
The report covering calendar year 2026 is due May 1, 2027.